‘Heated Rivalry’: Steamy export from a frigid place
In 2023, Jacob Tierney, a Canadian writer, director, and producer approached major U.S. streaming platforms with an idea. He wanted to adapt the novel, “Heated Rivalry” into a TV series.
“Heated Rivalry” was a romance novel about two male hockey players who play against each other in a professional hockey league and eventually fall in love. The series, as Tierney pitched it, would include explicit sex scenes between the two men.
You can see why the streaming executives and financiers had their doubts. A gay hockey romance doesn’t exactly scream mass appeal. For one thing, hockey isn’t a top-tier sport. It’s only the fifth-most-popular sport in the U.S., the biggest streaming market, and its appeal around the world is limited to a handful of cold-weather places.
Not only that, but the source material was a romance novel. As a genre, romance doesn’t get much respect in Hollywood: it’s considered predictable and formulaic. The central relationship would be between two men. And while there are gay characters and relationships on television, a show with a gay romance at its core—explicit scenes included—would probably not have the same appeal as a traditional series.
The executives listening to Jacob Tierney’s pitch didn’t say “no,” exactly. But they didn’t say “yes” either. They told him that they would finance his show only if he made substantial changes to the concept. Tierney, who is gay himself, said no. He would try his luck with a smaller producer.
He struck a deal with Crave, a Canadian streamer. Crave made the six-episode series for less than C$3 million per episode, a modest budget for a series like this. But the product was excellent. The show had emotional depth, genuine conflict, beautiful scenery, and a cross-cultural love story that appealed to gay and straight audiences alike. It was ready to air in November 2025, when a funny thing happened.
Someone at HBO Max saw an advance copy of the show, and wanted to get in on the action. Just nine days before the series was released on Crave in Canada, HBO Max paid Crave and Tierney for the rights to distribute the show in the United States and Australia.
The show quickly became a hit. Crave’s viewership grew 400 percent in the first week, making “Heated Rivalry” the most successful show in the Canadian platform’s history. It also found success outside hockey-mad Canada. It became HBO Max’s top-streaming show in the United States, passing even adaptations of Stephen King novels.
The entertainment industry was shocked at the show’s success. But maybe it shouldn’t have been.
Think back to all the reasons American executives might not have liked the original concept. It was based on a romance novel. (Ugh.) It had gay sex scenes. (Mmmm…) It was about hockey, of all sports. (Who cares about hockey?) Each of these was a reason, on the surface, not to like the proposal. But each also held a clue to the show’s eventual success.
Romance novels may not get much respect in Hollywood, but romance novels sell. Romance is the largest fiction genre by sales in North America, outselling mystery, science fiction, and literary fiction combined. Rachel Reid’s 2019 novel “Heated Rivalry” hit bestseller lists; the book is just one of six in a series called “Game Changers,” and it’s not the only one to be a bestseller. So clearly this story resonated beyond hockey fans and the gay community.
Next, gay romance stories have appeal far beyond gay audiences. And that goes for novels and television dramas. It’s true that you don’t see many steamy male-male romance scenes on mainstream Western streamers. But this type of content is popular in Asia. And do you know who likes to watch them? Young, primarily straight women.
Male-male romance has been on television in Asia for years. The genre started in Japan in the 1970s and quickly spread to China, Taiwan, South Korea, the Philippines, and Thailand. In Thailand, for example, there are dozens of male-male romance series made each year, and the women love it.
Even the hockey might have helped the series succeed. A gay romance about a popular sport—like Champions League soccer or American football—might have seemed implausible. But most viewers don’t know hockey very well, so they could get lost in the story without worrying about whether it was realistic.
“Heated Rivalry” exceeded all expectations. Tierney, the producer, didn’t compromise on his idea. The Canadian streamer Crave gave him the creative freedom that he needed to make an outstanding, bold, risky show. HBO Max came late to the party—we don’t know if they were among the streamers who initially passed on the project, but they have sure benefitted from the show’s popularity now that they have the rights to distribute it.
After seeing Heated Rivalry’s success in Canada, Australia, and the United States, HBO Max scrambled to get distribution rights for the rest of the world. Viewers across Asia, Latin America, and Europe can watch it on HBO Max or local streamers.
Jeff’s take
The show’s impact has gone beyond television. Canada is experiencing a boom of interest in all things “Heated Rivalry.”
Shane’s “cottage” has inspired a lot of interest. It’s a large house on a lake about 140 kilometers from Toronto. The cottage features exposed wood beams, a central granite fireplace and enormous glass windows facing the lake. It’s at once exposed (because of the windows) and intimate (because of how isolated it is), making it the perfect setting for episode six.
The architect, Trevor McIvor has been fielding requests for custom-designed cottages just like the one in the show. I have to say, if I had an extra C$2 million for a lake house, I’d want one just like that.
Even a fleece jacket that appeared in just a handful of scenes is now a collectors’ item. It was a white zip-up fleece that Shane wore during the Sochi Olympics. The jacket was made just for the show—it was not worn by actual Canadian athletes in 2014. But thousands of people signed a petition requesting that the fleece be offered for sale. A Canadian company is now making replicas of the jackets and donating part of the proceeds to charity.
The show’s costume designer can’t explain the jacket’s success. “You can never figure out what the public is going to decide is worth attention,” she said.
Great stories make learning English fun